April 8, 2025

Cold Case Murder of Karen Percifield Solved After 50 Years

Community Resource Consultants Inc. (CRCI)

Community Resource Consultants Inc. (CRCI) is a Michigan-based organization specializing in trauma rehabilitation medical case management. With over 34 years of experience, CRCI is dedicated to empowering survivors of catastrophic auto accidents to regain control of their lives and achieve both physical and emotional well-being. Their team of Licensed Master Social Workers (LMSWs) and Registered Nurses (RNs) are experts in navigating the complexities of today’s healthcare system, ensuring that survivors receive the necessary services for their recovery and rehabilitation. CRCI’s core values include advocacy, people, knowledge, and dependability, reflecting their commitment to being leading advocates and facilitators of long-term collaborative care.

News Summary

The long-unsolved murder of Karen Percifield, who was killed in 1976, has finally been resolved after advances in DNA technology identified Richard Sommerhalder as the killer. Thanks to familial DNA testing, the Santa Cruz County Sheriff’s Office has been able to provide closure to Percifield’s family and highlight the effectiveness of modern forensic methods in solving cold cases.

Cold Case Murder Mystery Finally Solved After Nearly 50 Years

In a heartwarming twist of fate, the nearly five-decade-long struggle to find justice for the brutal murder of Karen Percifield has come to a close. Thanks to advances in DNA technology and the dedicated work of investigators, the identity of her killer has been revealed: Richard Sommerhalder.

A Forgotten Tragedy

Karen Percifield was only 25 years old when her life was tragically cut short in 1976. Last seen while visiting her sister, she vanished after an argument at the Bayview Hotel. After a few long days of worry, the search came to a grim conclusion when her body was discovered in a ravine, brutally taken from the world by a grisly stabbing.

The Long Wait for Justice

For many years, the case remained a cold file, unsolved and gathering dust. Richard Sommerhalder surfaced as a person of interest shortly after the murder, but insufficient evidence left law enforcement unable to make an arrest. Despite his later conviction for the murders of two other women, the shadow of Percifield’s murder lingered unanswered. Sommerhalder tragically passed away in 1994, which meant he would never face justice for Karen’s death.

Embracing New Technology

In 2019, a team of detectives decided to take a fresh look at the case and submitted evidence for new DNA testing. While the initial database didn’t yield any matches, hope was not lost. The groundbreaking technique of familial DNA testing came into play, leading to the realization that Sommerhalder was indeed the one responsible for the heinous act committed so long ago. This modern approach has drastically changed the landscape of investigative work, allowing detectives to unravel the knots of history and bring clarity to families who have waited far too long.

Othram Laboratories, a key player in solving this case, has been making headlines for their cutting-edge technology. Unlike traditional methods that analyze just 20-24 markers of DNA, Othram’s advanced system examines hundreds of thousands of markers. This leap in forensic capability has allowed them to crack five cold cases across California just in the last month!

Families Rekindle Hope

The news of this resolution brings a wave of relief to Karen Percifield’s family, who have lived with the uncertainty and grief for decades. Her daughter, Meadow Shumake, expressed profound gratitude for finally having clarity on her mother’s death after a long and painful journey of unanswered questions. Meanwhile, Karen’s sister, Annie Goheen, reflected on the emotional rollercoaster of seeking justice and praised the advances in DNA technology that made this moment possible.

The resolve of this cold case also reflects the unwavering determination of the Santa Cruz County Sheriff’s Office. Their commitment to uncovering the truth, irrespective of how many years have passed, resonated through the community and offers hope that justice can be pursued well after the fact.

Moving Forward

As this case closes another chapter, it also highlights the ever-growing potential of DNA technology to breathe new life into unsolved crimes. With Othram expanding its work beyond cold cases to modern investigative efforts, the future looks increasingly bright for those seeking answers.

This identification marks a significant milestone as it represents the 59th cold case solved in California using innovative forensic technology. The excitement surrounding these advancements fuels optimism that even more families might one day find closure, no matter how long they have been left in the shadows of uncertainty.